Independent whisky comparison
Port Charlotte 10 vs Kilchoman Machir Bay
Port Charlotte 10 and Kilchoman Machir Bay are 91% alike across the six flavour axes. See where they align and where they differ.
Open this comparisonKey facts side by side
Key facts side by side
First whisky
Port Charlotte 10
Second whisky
Kilchoman Machir Bay
Age10NAS
Strength50% ABV46% ABV
CaskAmerikaans & Frans eikenBourbon & oloroso sherry
Peat8/108/10
OriginSchotland · IslaySchotland · Islay
Flavour profiles compared
Flavour profiles compared
Port Charlotte 10Kilchoman Machir Bay
smoke8 / 8
fruit6 / 6
sweetness6 / 6
oak5 / 4
spice5 / 7
maritime character7 / 7
Continue in the comparison tool
Continue in the comparison tool
Open both bottles in the interactive comparison. You can swap either whisky and inspect every flavour point.
More fixed comparisons
More fixed comparisons
Frequently asked questions
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between Port Charlotte 10 and Kilchoman Machir Bay?
In this model, the largest difference is on spice. Use cask, peat, strength and origin for context.
Which is smokier: Port Charlotte 10 or Kilchoman Machir Bay?
Port Charlotte 10 has the higher peat intensity of the two at 8/10.
Should I choose Port Charlotte 10 or Kilchoman Machir Bay?
Choose the profile closest to your taste. The values show intensity; they do not declare one whisky better.